
Today the 7th Review Conference of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW) was due to start under the presidency of His Excellency Ambassador Julien Thöni of Switzerland. It has been the most highly anticipated meeting of the CCW in over 15 years because one of the items on the agenda is the start of negotiations on a new legal instrument on lethal autonomous weapons systems.
After convening for only two hours today, the meeting does not have consensus on the agenda or the rules of procedure. The main sticking point is that the Russian Federation (Russia) wants to put limits on the participation of observers in the discussions. In the CCW observers mean not just NGOs but also international organizations like the ICRC, academics, regional organizations like the EU and observer states who haven’t yet joined the CCW.
The Russian delegate made the following statement:
“We are prepared to adopt the agenda, confirm the rules of procedure, and agree parameters for organisation of the work of this forum, only provided that the participation of non-state subjects is restricted in terms of opportunity to be present at plenary meetings, submitting working documents, and also making statements at one plenary meeting within the framework of a specially provided segment, exclusively after discussion by member states of all substantive agenda items, before moving towards the preparation of the final document of the Conference, and without any politicised overtones whatsoever.”
The underlying concern outlined by Russia was that the European Union had been “politicizing” the discussion in the CCW for a number of years and that should not be allowed. Thinking back over the CCW debates since 2022, many EU interventions outlined reported actions of the Russian Federation and the Russian military in Ukraine. For the Russian delegation this appears to be considered politicizing the CCW while the general public would probably consider it discussing the topics at hand. These actions indicate that Russia may be willing to kill the Review Conference to further its dispute with the EU.
A number of states spoke out against this proposal including Ireland, the United States, Panama, the United Kingdom, Mexico, Canada, and Austria, saying that the suggestion from Russia ran counter to the Rules of Procedure and established practice. The Irish Ambassador noted that the proposal by Russia “would seem to involve changing how observers participate, when they participate, and it appears potentially with the prospect of veto on what they say, which, as we understand it, is unnecessary given the chairs of meetings and the President already have powers regarding how a meeting should proceed. It would also, if we understand correctly, mean the entire end to a dedicated segment for observers, so they would only have one chance to speak at the end of a meeting, but with the content of their interventions constantly subject to veto.”
Mines Action Canada agrees that the proposal is unacceptable. After about an hour of discussion where there was no support for the Russian proposal, Russia still objected to adopting the rules of procedure and the agenda. It seems the spirit of compromise has not yet found the Russian delegation.
Following almost a full day of informal consultations attempting to find consensus, the Review Conference President made a decision. Tomorrow there will be consultations open to all delegations on lethal autonomous weapons systems tomorrow starting at 10am Geneva time to discuss the draft mandate put forward by the Peruvian Chair of Main Committee II. These consultations will be open to all delegations – High Contracting Parties and observers.
While tomorrow’s consultations on LAWS might help move the conversation forward on the potential mandate for negotiating a legally binding instrument on autonomous weapons systems, without an agreement on the formal opening of the meeting, it will be difficult to make actual progress.
Tomorrow’s consultations will not be broadcast on UN WebTV so we will have to rely on those in the room to let us know what is happening. Let's hope that states will be able to focus on the task at hand and get us closer to negotiations on autonomous weapons systems.
Do you like this page?